Editorial: 5% Civil Servant Wage Raise Affordable

In an editorial in the Bangkok Post, a contributor criticizes the 5% raise to be put into place for Thai civil servants based on the belief...

In an editorial in the Bangkok Post, a contributor criticizes the 5% raise to be put into place for Thai civil servants based on the belief that it is unaffordable, and would drag Thailand into a California or Greek-esque financial crisis. My editorial rebuts these unsubstantiated claims and provides solid evidence to demonstrate that the increase is affordable and reasonable.

By Karn G. Bulsuk


In the Post Bag’s editorial piece titled "Strapped for cash" on August 10, the author demonstrates a fundamental lack of knowledge on government and economics. The author's basic premise is that state official salaries should not be raised by 5% because the American and European economies are not doing well, and that budget cuts should be the basis of Thailand’s fiscal policy.

Economies in Asia have weathered the economic problems of the West relatively well, and are not affected as much as initially feared. In fact, the Revenue Department has reported that tax receipts since the beginning of the fiscal year have exceeded targets by as much as 30%. Coupled with more efficient tax collection, an expanded tax base and strong economic recovery, tax collection beyond targets is a pattern which is expected to continue.

An annual raise of 5% also needs to be put into perspective. A UN study has indicated that the wages of a civil servant ranges from 4,100 baht to 59,000 baht a month, dependant on job grade and years of service. Compared to the private sector, this is extremely low. We also need to consider that a 5% increase is a tiny fraction of what the private sector would provide, which is usually in the realm of a 10-15% annual raise.

The comparison to California and Greece is also logically unsound. Unlike California, Thailand is not constitutionally bound to a balanced budget and is able to utilize debt as a basic fiscal tool. Thailand’s use of deficit spending is nothing new, and is common throughout governments to continue to finance projects. Unlike Greece, Thailand is not bankrupt and has 149,000 million USD worth of foreign reserves: the 11th most in the world.

We must consider than given the increases in tax revenue, continued economic recovery and the fact that wages of civil servants are already low to start with, a 5% increase is more than affordable and should be welcomed, not condemned.

Comments

Name

5-why,8,advertising,8,amazon,4,analysis,14,anime,4,apple,1,aria,1,articles,15,asian business culture,7,Australia,6,bangkok,23,blackberry,6,business,11,case study,4,china,3,coaching,3,commentary,10,communication,2,consulting,2,corruption,1,cost cutting,1,creative commons,2,crisis,1,CSR,2,culture,7,customer service,4,deming,1,disruptive,2,download,12,editorial,47,education,2,entrepreneurship,8,environment,2,ethics,2,expatriate,2,fishbone diagram,2,food,2,genchi genbutsu,2,generation y,2,hansei,1,harvard business review,2,hong kong,7,Horenso,5,information,1,innovation,11,interesting clips,6,internet,2,iphone,3,IT Audit,1,japan,15,kaizen,28,korea,2,KPS Video Express,3,laos,4,leadership,1,lean,5,live in bangkok like a local,4,management,9,marketing,30,Melbourne,6,mieruka,11,movie,1,new year,5,obituary,2,opinion,35,opportunity,8,PDCA,9,personal reflections,5,photo essay,1,photo walk,1,photography,16,poster,1,project management,1,proposal,1,published,5,quality control,4,quotes,7,research,1,review,4,sales,2,saving money,1,segmentation,1,self reflection,1,shared,1,singapore,2,social media,1,software piracy,2,standard chartered,1,status,1,teaching,1,technology,19,telecoms,8,thai floods,12,thailand,27,the hong kong I remember,3,The Toyota Way,39,thought leadership,3,threat,1,toyota,8,toyota production system,39,travel,11,venice,1,Virtual Tour,1,Visuals,13,wallchart,1,wikicommons,1,Wikipedia,2,working,1,zarticles,11,
ltr
item
Karn Bulsuk: Full Speed Ahead: Editorial: 5% Civil Servant Wage Raise Affordable
Editorial: 5% Civil Servant Wage Raise Affordable
http://2.bp.blogspot.com/_ilVgx1VRxIY/TGk2-JIGPXI/AAAAAAAAAhs/KyfUbTuUJc8/s400/money.closeup.jpg
http://2.bp.blogspot.com/_ilVgx1VRxIY/TGk2-JIGPXI/AAAAAAAAAhs/KyfUbTuUJc8/s72-c/money.closeup.jpg
Karn Bulsuk: Full Speed Ahead
https://www.bulsuk.com/2010/08/editorial-5-civil-servant-wage-raise.html
https://www.bulsuk.com/
https://www.bulsuk.com/
https://www.bulsuk.com/2010/08/editorial-5-civil-servant-wage-raise.html
true
1176442693905561237
UTF-8
All posts loaded No posts found VIEW ALL Read more Reply Cancel reply Delete By Home PAGES POSTS View All RECOMMENDED FOR YOU LABEL ARCHIVE SEARCH ALL POSTS No posts found Home Sunday Monday Tuesday Wednesday Thursday Friday Saturday Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat January February March April May June July August September October November December Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec Just now 1 minute ago $$1$$ minutes ago 1 hour ago $$1$$ hours ago Yesterday $$1$$ days ago $$1$$ weeks ago more than 5 weeks ago Followers Follow THIS CONTENT IS LOCKED STEP 1: Share. STEP 2: Click the link you shared to unlock Copy All Code Select All Code All codes were copied to your clipboard Can not copy the codes / texts, please press [CTRL]+[C] (or CMD+C with Mac) to copy